Skip to content
Disruptive Lab

Guide European rules

Can a foreign state reach your EU data?

Where your data sits matters less than who controls it, and the GDPR and the Data Act tell you what to ask and what to put in the contract.

Published
Updated
Reading time
8 min read
Editor
David Lahuta

In short

A data centre in Europe does not decide on its own who can be ordered to hand your data over. Under US law, an order to a provider of communication or cloud services reaches data in its possession, custody or control, wherever that data is stored.3 EU law answers on its side. The GDPR recognises a foreign court order or authority decision to hand over personal data only when it rests on an international agreement, such as a treaty on mutual legal assistance.2 Since 12 September 2025 the Data Act does the same for other data held by cloud providers in the EU.5 This protects the data in law, but a provider can still be caught between two legal systems.4 So the questions to settle are who controls your data, under which law, and what the contract says when an order arrives.

What did France decide, and why?

On 26 January 2026 the French government announced that Visio, a meeting tool built by its interministerial digital directorate DINUM, will be rolled out to all state services by 2027.1 It is to become the one video meeting tool for state employees.1

The government gave its reasons in its own release. The aim is to end the use of solutions from outside Europe and to keep public electronic communications secure and confidential.1 It said that a wide mix of meeting tools weakens data security, creates strategic dependence on outside infrastructure and adds cost.1 Visio is hosted with a provider holding SecNumCloud, the security label of ANSSI, the French national cybersecurity agency.1 The minister responsible said the state could not risk its scientific exchanges, sensitive data and strategic innovations being exposed to actors from outside Europe.1

This is a decision of one state about its own services. It sets no rule for companies. But it asks, at state level, the same question many managing directors ask about their own systems.

Does hosting in Europe keep a foreign government out?

Not on its own. Where the servers stand is one question. Who controls the data, and under which country's law that company falls, is another.

The CLOUD Act, a US law of March 2018, added a short section to the US Code. It says that a provider of electronic communication or remote computing services must meet its duties under US law to preserve, back up or disclose a customer's communications and records within its possession, custody or control, "regardless of whether" they are located inside or outside the United States.3

The European Data Protection Board and the European Data Protection Supervisor assessed this law in 2019 for the European Parliament. In their reading it gives US authorities the right to require data stored abroad by a service provider subject to US jurisdiction.4 They also noted its limits. It governs targeted requests in specific criminal investigations, with procedural safeguards, and does not authorise systematic or large scale collection.4

They left two questions open. Does the law apply to EU companies with some presence in the United States? And how is "control" read for EU subsidiaries of US companies?4 Those questions are the reason a buyer should ask about the provider's owner, not only its address.

Where your data is and who runs it What a non-EU order can do, in our reading of the sources
Your own servers, run by your own people An order would be addressed to you, an EU company, and is recognised in the EU only through an international agreement2
A provider established in the EU, with no parent or presence outside it The same, the provider answers to EU law25
A European data centre of a provider subject to US jurisdiction The provider can be ordered directly, wherever the data is stored3; EU law does not recognise the order without an agreement, so the provider faces a conflict of laws4
An EU provider with an office or parent in the United States An open question in the view of the European data protection authorities4

What does the GDPR say?

The GDPR applies to processing in the context of an establishment in the EU, whether or not the processing itself takes place in the EU.2

Article 48 is the rule on foreign orders. A judgment of a court or a decision of an administrative authority of a country outside the EU that requires a controller or processor to transfer or disclose personal data may only be recognised or enforced if it is based on an international agreement, such as a mutual legal assistance treaty, in force between that country and the EU or a member state.2 The regulation's recitals add that the extraterritorial application of such foreign laws may breach international law.2

The European data protection authorities drew the practical consequence. A request from a foreign authority is not in itself a legal ground for a transfer.4 Where a mutual legal assistance treaty exists, EU companies should generally refuse direct requests and refer the authority to that treaty.4 Between the EU and the United States such an agreement has been in force since 1 February 2010.4 Their conclusion was that unless a CLOUD Act warrant is recognised through an international agreement, the lawfulness of the transfer cannot be established, apart from exceptional cases where a person's vital interests are at stake.4

The cost of getting it wrong is real. A transfer of personal data that breaks the GDPR's transfer rules can be fined up to EUR 20 million or 4% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher.2 That is the bind the authorities described. A provider that obeys the foreign order may breach EU law, and one that refuses may face sanctions under US law.4

What does the Data Act add for data that is not personal?

The GDPR covers personal data. Much of what a company holds is not personal, for example prices, designs, production data and contracts between firms. For this data there is the Data Act, which has applied since 12 September 2025.5

Its rule on foreign access binds providers of data processing services. The regulation defines these as services that give on demand network access to a shared pool of computing resources, which in practice means cloud and edge services.56 Article 32 asks four things of them.

  1. Prevent it. They must take all adequate technical, organisational and legal measures, contracts included, to prevent foreign governmental access to non-personal data held in the EU where it would conflict with EU or national law.5
  2. Recognise only an agreement. A foreign court or authority decision to hand over such data is recognised only if it rests on an international agreement.5
  3. Without an agreement, only under conditions. The foreign system must require a reasoned, proportionate and specific order, and a court there must review the provider's objection and be able to weigh the interests protected by EU law.5 Even then the provider hands over the minimum amount of data.5
  4. Tell the customer. The provider must inform the customer of the request before complying, except where the request serves law enforcement, and only for as long as that is needed.5

Article 28 adds transparency. Each provider must publish on its website the jurisdiction to which the infrastructure of each of its services is subject, and a general description of its measures against foreign governmental access, and its contracts must point to that page.5 The Commission sums up the purpose plainly. Non-personal data stored in the EU is protected against unlawful foreign government access requests.6

What should you ask a provider, and what goes in the contract?

You can settle most of this with your providers in writing. These questions cover it.

  • Which company runs our data, and which country's law applies to it and to its parent company?
  • Where are our data, backups and logs stored, and from where can support staff reach them?
  • Has the provider published the jurisdiction of each service and its measures against foreign access, as the Data Act requires, and does the contract point to that page?5
  • Does the data processing agreement say that personal data is processed only on our documented instructions, transfers included, unless EU or national law requires otherwise, and that the provider then tells us before acting on it, unless that law forbids it?2
  • What does the contract say happens when a foreign authority asks for our data? Notice to us first, a referral to the international agreement, an objection where the law allows it, and only the minimum data.45
  • Who holds the keys to our encrypted data, the provider or we ourselves?
  • Which of our data is sensitive enough to keep with a provider that answers only to EU law, or on our own servers?

What does this mean for your systems?

Not every system needs to move. Start with a short map of what you hold, in three groups. Personal data of customers and staff. Data that would hurt you in a competitor's hands, such as prices, designs and contract terms. And everything else. The first two groups decide where your systems should run and which provider fits.

Then look at the way out. The Data Act also helps here, because from 12 January 2027 cloud providers may no longer charge customers for switching to another provider.5 A system whose data you can export in full, and which can run in a public cloud, a hybrid cloud or your own data centre, keeps that choice open. Who answers to which law can then be a decision you make, rather than one made for you.

Next step

If it would help, we can meet briefly and map together where your data sits today, which providers handle it and who could be ordered to hand it over. Where a system would be better placed elsewhere, we can also look at how custom business systems and applications can run in the cloud, a hybrid cloud or your own data centre. What you do with it afterwards is entirely your decision.

Custom business systems and applications

Sources

  1. 1. DINUM, French interministerial digital directorate, Souveraineté numérique, l'État généralise Visio, sa solution de visioconférence sécurisée et souveraine à destination des agents publics, press release, 26 January 2026. Read on 17 November 2026
  2. 2. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2016/679, General Data Protection Regulation, Official Journal L 119, 4 May 2016. Read on 17 November 2026
  3. 3. United States Code, Title 18, Section 2713, Required preservation and disclosure of communications and records (added by the CLOUD Act, 23 March 2018), U.S. Government Publishing Office. Read on 17 November 2026
  4. 4. European Data Protection Board and European Data Protection Supervisor, joint response to the LIBE Committee on the impact of the US CLOUD Act, with its annex, 10 July 2019. Read on 17 November 2026
  5. 5. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 on harmonised rules on fair access to and use of data (Data Act), Official Journal L, 22 December 2023. Read on 17 November 2026
  6. 6. European Commission, Data Act explained. Read on 17 November 2026

Change log

  1. Published.

Let's talk about your project

Leave us your contact details and we will get back to you with a date. Free and without obligation.

With the country code, for example +44.

We use your details only to answer you. Privacy notice

This form is protected from automated submissions by Google reCAPTCHA. Google Privacy Policy (opens in a new window) Google Terms of Service (opens in a new window)

Or contact us directly

Write to us office@disruptivelab.dev
Call us +420 777 702 032

Our preferred language of communication is English.

All contact details and addresses